Honors AP Calculus Quiz
3/4/1999

(rev. 3/8/1999, 11/14/2002)

1. Woody is coasting backward down a hill. At time t = 0 sec., he slams the accelerator to the floor, and the car's velocity is given by v(t) = 2 + t for t 0.
-- (a) Find the time at which v = 0.
-- (b) Find net displacement for 1 t 9.
-- (c) Find total distance traveled for 1 t 9.

2. A rectangle of length L and width W has constant area of 1200 sq. in. The length changes at a rate of dL/dt in./min.
-- (a) Find dW/dt in terms of W and dL/dt.
-- (b) At a particular instant, the length is increasing at 6 in./min. and the width is decreasing at 2 in./min. Find the dimensions of the rectangle at this instant.
-- (c) At the instant mentioned in part (b), is the length of the diagonal increasing or decreasing? At what rate?

3. (original version) The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers needs to construct a road over Mt. Sinai, which cannot be bypassed because of terrain. The elevation profile of the mountain is closely approximated by y = 3 + sin(x/2), where x is horizontal displacement (0 x 2p) and units are in km. Assume that the life-cycle cost of a surface road is 5y|y'| million dollars per km, and assume that the life-cycle cost of a horizontal tunnel is $30 million per km regardless of elevation. Draw a diagram and find the elevation (to the nearest meter) of the tunnel entrance such that the life-cycle cost of the route up and through Mt. Sinai and back down is minimized.

Note: The life-cycle cost of a surface road is assumed here to vary jointly with elevation and absolute slope, using 5 as the constant of proportionality.

SOLUTION TO #3 (original version)
Almost everyone drew the same diagram, letting x denote the horizontal point at which the tunnel begins. This is not really legitimate unless we use a different variable (say, t) to be the independent variable in the elevation function. The other place where nearly everyone stumbled was in failing to note that the cost function 5y|y'| uses elevation and slope information that change continuously depending on horizontal position. In other words, we will need to use an integral involving 5y|y'|, not simply a value computed for a single x.

The use of arc length instead of horizontal distance turns out not to make a huge difference. Let's work the problem first "naively," then more intelligently using arc length.

If the tunnel enters at x, it exits at 2p x, so the (inaccurate) cost function is B(x)= [integral from 0 to x of 5y(t)y'(t)dt] + 30(2p - x-x) + [integral from 2pi-x to 2pi of 5y(t)y'(t)dt] = 2fnInt(5y(t)y'(t),t,0,x) + 60(p x). To get a sense of the behavior of this function, plot it over the only domain that makes sense, namely 0 to p. What you'll see is that the function is decreasing everywhere, so that the minimum occurs when x = p, y = 4, and tunnel length = 2p 2x = 0; in other words, the tunnel is not cost-effective at all and should not be built. The road should be laid over the mountain. (Note: In the real world, the profile function would show the road going over a mountain pass, not a mountaintop. Also, the road is far too steep near the base to carry vehicle traffic, since y'(0) = 0.5.)

TI-83 computational notes: By using the logically invalid notation fnInt(5Y1Y2,X,0,X), where Y2 denotes the function 0.5cos(X/2), you can roughly double the speed of the graphing. Be sure to set xres = 5 in the WINDOW setting, though, or you'll be waiting forever.

As mentioned above, the function B(x) is inaccurate because it assumes the sloped, curved road is straight and flat. A better cost function, employing the arc length differential ds = (1+(y')2) dx, would be C(x) = 2*[integral from 0 to x of 5y(t)y'(t)sqrt(1+(y'(t))^2)] + 60(pi-x), or, to use the logically sloppy but much faster TI-83 notation, 2fnInt(5Y1Y2*sqrt(1+Y2^2),X,0,X)+60(pX). Like the function B(x) we plotted before, C(x) is also decreasing on [0, p]. Therefore, the conclusion is again that the tunnel is not cost-effective.

But . . . should we even use the calculator at all? Using nothing more than pencil and paper, we can get dC/dx = 10yy'sqrt(1+(y')^2) - 60, courtesy of the second form of the FTC. We also know that y<=4 on the domain of interest, and 0<=y'<=0.5 on the domain of interest. Thus the first term in our expression for dC/dx can never possibly exceed 10*4*0.5*sqrt(1+0.25), which is much less than 60. Thus dC/dx is always negative. No calculator required! Or, if you insist on using your calculator, please just graph dC/dx, which is very speedy--no long wait for messy computations. (If dC/dx did have a zero, graphing dC/dx would still be the way to go, since you wouldn't be hunting for a flat spot on C(x) and wouldn't be desperately trying to zoom in on it.)

3A. (take-home version) Change $30 million to $1 million; in other words, a new tunnel-boring machine has been found that cuts the cost of tunnel construction by a factor of 30. What is the optimal elevation of the tunnel entrance, to the nearest meter? Also calculate the total cost of the road.

3B. (Will Segal's "Problem With a Twist") Suppose that the cost per km of building the tunnel is unknown, but that for bureaucratic reasons it has been predetermined that the elevation of the tunnel entrance is to be 3500 m (i.e., 3.5 km, or halfway between the 3 km base of the mountain and the 4 km summit). For what cost per km of tunnel construction would this have been the optimal decision to make?


Return to Mr. Hansen's home page

Return to Mathematics Department home page

Return to St. Albans home page

Last updated: 17 Oct 2004